The Island’s MP, Andrew Turner, took part in a short debate last night called by the MP for New Forest West, Desmond Swayne, about the Lymington River and the Habitats Directive. During the debate Mr Turner pointed out that Open Port Duty Regulations meant that the only way in which the Lymington Harbour Commissioners could prevent the new ferries from operating was if they were proven to be unsafe, and that extensive sea trials and investigations had not produced evidence to suggest such concerns, nor that they would cause adverse environmental problems.
Mr Swayne argued that a full Environmental Impact Assessment was required rather than the more limited Appropriate Assessment that is currently being produced. Huw Irranca-Davies the Minister from the Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs gave a detailed response setting out the history of the situation and the legal position. He called for Wightlink to work with all those involved in preparing the Appropriate Assessment to bring it to a swift conclusion.
Speaking after the debate Mr Turner said :
“I welcome a number of points made during this debate. This is a complex legal situation with a number of regulators and agencies involved but everyone accepts it is imperative that the ferries continue to run on this route. The Minister made it clear that he understood the importance of this ‘lifeline service’ to the Isle of Wight, a point I have made strongly to his officials. He also recognised the safety problems with the old ferries. Mr Swayne put on record that he is committed to a ‘thriving ferry service’ recognising that it is vital not only for the Island but for his own constituents as well. I shall continue to work with Wightlink and the different bodies involved to help find a solution.
“The Minister said that there was nothing unlawful in Wightlink bringing the new ferries into service, but urged them to reflect carefully on the situation and not to do anything hasty. Although there are differences of opinion on what exactly needs to be done, and when, everyone is working towards the same goal. A DEFRA minister was called to answer this debate, but his officials are working closely with the Dept. of Transport on this issue.”
Mr Turner added that he was grateful to departmental officials who had been dealing with him and his office and to Mr Swayne for his courtesy in calling on him to him make his points during his fifteen minute speech.
The text of the full debate can be found at :
http://pubs1.tso.parliament.uk/pa/cm200708/cmhansrd/cm081119/debtext/81119-0019.htm#08111982000004
END Contact : Andrew Turner’s office 01983 530808
